Medicare Supplement vs. Advantage in San Antonio, 2027
Figures last verified: 2026-11-21
Have questions about your Medicare options?
TL;DR
- A Medicare Supplement plus a drug plan costs more each month and lets you use any doctor or hospital in the country that takes Medicare. Medicare Advantage usually costs less each month, uses a network, and caps what you pay in a year.
- For 2027, Bexar County has 38 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage that anyone with Medicare can join, and 27 of them have no monthly plan premium.
- Their yearly in-network maximums run from $2,800 to $9,850. That number, not the premium, is the one to compare first.
- If you choose a Supplement, you also need a stand-alone drug plan. Texas has 10 of them for 2027, priced from $5.30 to $199.00 a month, and none has a $0 premium.
- The timing rule matters more than any plan detail: a Supplement is easiest to get in your first 6 months with Part B. After that, companies can ask health questions.
Here is the short answer. In San Antonio, a Medicare Supplement is the choice that costs more every month and covers the most, with no network. Medicare Advantage is the choice that costs less every month, uses a local network, and puts a yearly ceiling on your costs. Neither one is right for everybody. The way to choose is to compare your worst year, not your average month, and to know before you start whether you can switch later.
Let’s go through it the way we would at the kitchen table, with the real 2027 numbers for Bexar County.
What are the two paths, in plain words?
Everybody starts with Original Medicare: Part A for hospital stays and Part B for doctors and outpatient care. You pay the Part B premium on either path. Then you pick one of two ways to fill the gaps.
Path 1: Original Medicare plus a Medicare Supplement plus a Part D drug plan. The Supplement, also called Medigap, pays most of what Original Medicare leaves behind, like the 20% you would otherwise owe on doctor bills. There is no network. Any doctor or hospital in the country that accepts Medicare accepts you. You pay three premiums: Part B, the Supplement and the drug plan.
Path 2: a Medicare Advantage plan. A private plan takes over your Part A and Part B coverage, and most plans in Bexar County include drug coverage. You pay copays as you go, up to a yearly maximum. Most plans use a network of local doctors and hospitals, and many add dental, vision or hearing benefits.
That is the give and take. One path buys freedom and predictability with a higher monthly bill. The other trades a network and copays for a lower monthly bill and a cap.
What does Medicare Advantage look like in Bexar County for 2027?
The table below sums up the 2027 plans anyone with Medicare can join in Bexar County. Special Needs Plans, for people with Medicaid, certain chronic conditions or a nursing home level of care, are left out because not everyone can join them.
| Bexar County, 2027 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage | Count or range |
|---|---|
| Plans anyone with Medicare can join | 38 |
| Of those, with no monthly plan premium | 27 |
| HMO or HMO-POS plans | 25 |
| PPO plans, local or regional | 13 |
| Yearly in-network maximum, lowest to highest | $2,800 to $9,850 |
| Plans with a yearly maximum of $4,000 or less | 13 |
Source: CMS Medicare Advantage and Part D Landscape Source File, contract year 2027 (October 2026 release), Bexar County, TX, via the Ambrose Brain, pulled November 21, 2026. Plans anyone can join: 32 renewing plans plus 6 new ones.
Two things jump out. First, every plan with a yearly maximum of $4,000 or less is an HMO. The PPOs, which let you see doctors outside the network for a higher share, have maximums from $6,350 to $9,850. Second, 4 plans carry the highest maximum on the list, $9,850, and 3 of those 4 have no monthly premium. A $0 premium and a $9,850 ceiling is a real bet on staying healthy.
On the drug side, the most any plan’s drug deductible can be for 2027 is $700, and your yearly cost for covered Part D drugs stops at $2,400. Those two rules are the same on both paths.
What does the Supplement path cost to set up?
We do not quote Supplement premiums on this site. They depend on your age, your ZIP code, whether you use tobacco and the company, and they change. What we can show is the shape of the cost.
On this path you pay:
- The Part B premium, which you pay on either path.
- The Supplement premium, every month, whether you see a doctor or not. In exchange, a plan like Plan G leaves you paying little beyond the yearly Part B deductible.
- A stand-alone Part D drug plan premium. For 2027, Texas has 10 stand-alone drug plans, down from 12 in 2026, with monthly premiums from $5.30 to $199.00. None of them has a $0 premium for 2027.
Source: CMS Medicare Advantage and Part D Landscape Source Files, contract years 2026 and 2027, Texas PDP region, via the Ambrose Brain, pulled November 21, 2026.
So the honest comparison is three premiums added together on one side, against one plan premium plus copays up to a cap on the other. The Supplement path almost always costs more each month. Not everybody can afford that, and that is not a failure. It is one of two good paths.
If you want to run your own numbers, our Medigap vs Medicare Advantage cost calculator lets you plug in real quotes side by side, and our Plan G vs Plan N answer explains the two Supplement plans most people compare.
Why does timing matter more than the plan?
Because one of these doors is easier to walk back through than the other.
With Medicare Advantage, you can change plans every year during the fall enrollment period, and there is a second window from January 1 to March 31. People do use it. In CMS’s 2027 Star Ratings data, the share of members who chose to leave their plan during 2025 was 14% for UnitedHealthcare’s H0609 contract, 24% for Humana’s H0028 contract and 31% for Devoted Health’s H7993 contract, all of which sell plans in Bexar County.
Source: CMS 2027 Star Ratings Data Table, measure “Members Choosing to Leave the Plan” (measurement period January 1 to December 31, 2025), contracts H0609, H0028 and H7993, via the Ambrose Brain, pulled November 21, 2026. Star Ratings data belongs to the contract, not to one plan.
A Supplement is different. You get a 6-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts the month your Part B begins and you are 65 or older. During those 6 months, a company has to sell you any Supplement it offers, without asking about your health. After that window closes, a company can ask health questions and can turn you down or charge more, unless a specific situation gives you a guaranteed right.
So the practical rule is this. If you think you may ever want a Supplement, the easiest time to get one is at the start. Moving from a Supplement to Medicare Advantage later is usually simple. Moving the other way can be hard. We explain the Texas details on our page about Medicare Supplement open enrollment in Texas.
How do you actually compare them? Four questions
Go in this order. Your health first. Your budget second. Your doctors, your hospital and your prescriptions third. Dental, vision and hearing last.
1. What does your worst year look like?
Add up the Medicare Advantage plan’s yearly premium and its yearly maximum. That is roughly the most a bad year costs you for covered in-network care, before drugs. Then add up a year of Supplement and drug plan premiums plus the Part B deductible. If the two totals are close, the network question decides it. If the Supplement total is far higher than you can carry, Medicare Advantage with a low maximum may be the steadier choice for your budget.
2. How much care do you use?
Bexar County figures from the CDC show that 33.5% of adults have high blood pressure and 13.9% have diagnosed diabetes. These are county figures for all adults, not a prediction for you. But if you manage a condition with regular specialist visits, copays add up, and the yearly maximum becomes your real cost. If you rarely see a doctor, you may never come close to it.
Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, PLACES county estimates, Bexar County, TX, 2023 data.
3. Are your doctors and hospital in the network?
This is where San Antonio choices get specific. One plan may include Methodist and not Baptist, or University Health and not CHRISTUS. A Supplement does not care. With Medicare Advantage, we check every doctor you see and the hospital you would go to, on every plan you are considering, before you enroll.
4. Do you travel or split the year somewhere else?
If you spend months with family out of state, an HMO’s network will not travel with you except for emergencies. A PPO helps some. A Supplement works anywhere in the country that takes Medicare. Our page on Medicare when you travel goes deeper.
What we see most often in San Antonio
People who are still healthy, watch their budget and stay close to home often start with Medicare Advantage and a low yearly maximum. People who want any doctor, travel often, or have a condition that sends them to specialists across town often lean toward a Supplement, if they can carry the premiums and they are inside their open enrollment window.
Neither is a wrong answer. The wrong move is choosing on the monthly premium alone, or missing the Supplement window without knowing it existed.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Medicare Supplement or Medicare Advantage cheaper in San Antonio for 2027?
Month to month, Medicare Advantage usually costs less: 27 of the 38 Bexar County plans anyone can join have no monthly plan premium for 2027. Over a year with a lot of care, the answer can flip. Call The Insurance Space at 866-717-8683 and we compare both with your own doctors and drugs.
Can I switch from Medicare Advantage to a Supplement later?
You can apply, but outside your 6-month Medigap open enrollment period, a company can ask health questions and may turn you down unless you have a guaranteed right in your situation. That is why we talk about this before your first plan, not after. Call us at 866-717-8683 and we check your dates.
Do I need a separate drug plan with a Medicare Supplement?
Yes. Supplements do not include drug coverage, so you add a stand-alone Part D plan. Texas has 10 of them for 2027, and none has a $0 monthly premium. The Insurance Space runs your drug list on each one with you at 866-717-8683.
Plan counts are for Bexar County, TX, from the CMS contract year 2027 landscape file, pulled November 21, 2026. This article is general information, not insurance, medical, tax or legal advice, and it is not a recommendation of any plan. The right choice depends on your health, your budget and your doctors. Call The Insurance Space at 866-717-8683 or book a review and we will compare both paths with you. There is no obligation to enroll.