Free Tools
Medigap vs Medicare Advantage Cost Calculator
A Medicare Supplement and a Medicare Advantage plan are a give and take. One costs more each month and leaves little to pay when you get care. The other costs less each month and you pay as you go, up to a yearly limit. Enter the premiums from your quotes to see your yearly cost both ways, in a light year and a heavy year.
Compare your yearly cost
Educational estimate only, using the premiums you enter. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere. Your Part B premium is the same on both paths, so it is left out.
Enter the four amounts above to compare.
For reference, Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage in Bexar County have yearly out-of-pocket maximums from $2,800 to $9,850 for 2027, and premiums from $0 to $138 a month (CMS Medicare Advantage / Part D Landscape file, contract year 2027, Bexar County, TX).
How the calculator works
- Supplement path, any year: 12 months of the Plan G premium, plus 12 months of the drug plan premium, plus the Part B deductible ($283 for 2026). Plan G pays the rest of what Original Medicare approves after that deductible.
- Medicare Advantage path, light year: 12 months of the plan premium, with little or no care used.
- Medicare Advantage path, heavy year: 12 months of the premium plus the full yearly out-of-pocket maximum, the most you would pay for covered in-network care.
- Drugs: both paths share the same yearly Part D out-of-pocket cap ($2,400 for 2027), so drug copays are left out of the comparison.
Cost is only part of the choice. A Supplement lets you see any doctor in the country who takes Medicare, with no network. Medicare Advantage usually works inside a network and often adds dental, vision and hearing. Read our Medicare Supplement guide for San Antonio and 2027 Medicare Advantage guide for San Antonio.
Common questions about comparing costs
Which costs less, a Medicare Supplement or Medicare Advantage?
It depends on how much care you use. Medicare Advantage often has a lower monthly premium but you pay copays as you go, up to a yearly limit. A Supplement usually costs more each month but leaves very little to pay when you get care. It is a give and take, not better or worse. Call The Insurance Space at 866-717-8683 and we will run the numbers with your real quotes.
Why do I have to enter the premiums myself?
Supplement and plan premiums depend on your age, ZIP code, tobacco use and the insurance company, and there is no single official price list for San Antonio. Use real quotes so the comparison means something. Call The Insurance Space at 866-717-8683 and we can get them for you.
Does this include my Part B premium?
No. You pay the Part B premium either way, so it does not change the comparison. The calculator compares only what is different between the two paths.
What about prescription drugs?
Drug costs depend on your exact medications. Both paths are protected by the same yearly Part D out-of-pocket cap, so the calculator adds your drug plan premium but not your drug copays. Call The Insurance Space at 866-717-8683 and we will check your drug list.
Sources
- CMS: 2026 Medicare Parts A and B premiums and deductibles
- Medicare.gov: Compare Medigap plan benefits
- Medicare.gov: Compare Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage
- CMS Medicare Advantage / Part D Landscape file, contract year 2027, Bexar County, TX
Last verified: 2026-11-16. Part B deductible shown is the latest year CMS has published (2026).
Want real quotes to plug in?
A licensed San Antonio agent can pull Supplement and Medicare Advantage quotes for your ZIP code and walk you through the give and take, at no cost.
We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.